Six students , with distinct heights, compare their heights and make the following observations.
- : is taller than .
- : is the shortest of all.
- : is taller than only one student.
- : is taller than but is not the tallest
The number of students that are taller than is the same as the number of students shorter than ____________.
View worked solution
Answer: C
Let us arrange the six students in descending order of their heights from 1 (tallest) to 6 (shortest):
1 (Tallest) > 2 > 3 > 4 > 5 > 6 (Shortest)
Using the given observations, we can determine their positions step-by-step:
- Observation II: is the shortest of all.
- Observation III: is taller than only one student (which must be ).
- Observation I & IV: is taller than , and is taller than . This gives the relative order: .
We also know is not the tallest (so cannot be at Position 1).
The remaining positions for and are 1, 2, 3, and 4. Since cannot be at 1, the only possible assignment to maintain the order is:
- The only remaining position (Position 1) must be occupied by :
Thus, the unique height order from tallest to shortest is:
P > T > S > R > U > Q
Now, let's answer the question:
- The number of students taller than (who is at position 4) is 3 (namely and ).
- We need to find the student who has exactly 3 students shorter than them.
- Looking at our order, the students shorter than are and (exactly 3 students).
Therefore, the blank should be filled with S.
Free practice · Your answers on this page are not saved.
